You’ve decided it’s time to invest in SEO to grow your business. But with so many SEO agencies claiming to have the secret to higher rankings and more leads, how do you know which one to trust?
This decision isn’t like choosing a new software tool or hiring a social media manager. SEO is a long-term investment, and choosing the wrong agency could cost you more than just money—it could waste valuable time and potentially damage your website’s credibility with search engines.
To find a high-quality, national SEO agency that delivers real results, treat the hiring process like a job interview. Ask the right questions, and you’ll quickly separate the professionals from those just looking for a quick paycheck.
(freepik/Freepik)
1. How long have you been doing SEO?
Experience is one of the most valuable assets an SEO agency can offer. While it’s possible to learn SEO from books and courses, nothing compares to hands-on experience in a constantly evolving industry.
Search engines update their algorithms frequently, and strategies that worked five years ago may be obsolete today. An agency with years of experience has weathered these changes and understands how to adapt. A company new to SEO may be skilled in current trends, but will it still be effective as the industry evolves again?
2. What’s your approach to improving search rankings?
There’s no universal SEO formula, but a reputable agency should have a clear, strategic approach that includes:
- Website Audits: Identifying technical issues, keyword gaps, and optimization opportunities.
- On-Page Optimization: Improving website structure, title tags, meta descriptions, site speed, and mobile responsiveness.
- Content Strategy: Creating high-quality, relevant content that supports keyword goals.
- Off-Page SEO: Building authority through high-quality backlinks and online mentions.
Be cautious of any agency that avoids discussing their strategy in detail or claims they have a “secret formula” for SEO success. Transparency is key.
3. Can you provide examples of past client success?
A trustworthy SEO agency should have a portfolio of past results. Ask for case studies, testimonials, or performance metrics from previous clients.
Look for agencies that can demonstrate long-term success, not just short-term ranking boosts. SEO should be about sustainable growth, not quick wins that disappear after a Google update.
4. What’s the longest you’ve retained a client?
Client retention says a lot about an agency’s reliability. Businesses don’t stick around unless they’re seeing measurable value.
While occasional client turnover is normal, an agency with a strong track record of long-term partnerships is more likely to provide consistent results and reliable service.
5. How do you measure SEO success?
SEO is about more than just rankings. A professional agency should track key performance indicators (KPIs) such as:
- Keyword Rankings: Tracking improvements in search visibility.
- Organic Traffic: Measuring the number of visitors coming from search engines.
- Lead Generation & Conversions: Assessing how SEO contributes to actual business growth.
- Bounce Rates & User Engagement: Ensuring visitors find valuable, relevant content on your site.
Ask how frequently they provide reports and what metrics they prioritize. If they focus only on rankings without connecting them to business growth, that’s a red flag.
6. How do you keep up with algorithm updates?
Google makes thousands of updates to its search algorithm every year. Most are minor, but some (like Panda, Penguin, and Core Updates) can significantly impact rankings.
A quality SEO agency stays ahead of these changes by:
- Monitoring industry trends and updates from Google.
- Analyzing data to spot shifts in search behavior.
- Adjusting strategies to align with best practices.
If an agency seems unaware of major algorithm updates, it may not be keeping up with industry changes.
7. Do you follow Google’s best practices?
Google has clear guidelines for ethical SEO practices. Avoid agencies that:
- Promise instant rankings: SEO takes time. Shortcuts often lead to penalties.
- Use black-hat tactics: This includes keyword stuffing, buying backlinks, or cloaking content.
- Ignore user experience: Search rankings prioritize user engagement and relevance, not just technical tricks.
Make sure your SEO agency prioritizes long-term success over short-term gains.
8. What’s your link-building strategy?
Backlinks (links from other sites to yours) play a crucial role in SEO. However, not all backlinks are beneficial.
- Quality over quantity: A few authoritative links are worth more than hundreds of spammy ones.
- Natural link-building: Good agencies earn links through content marketing, guest posts, and PR, not paid link schemes.
- Reputation matters: Avoid agencies that get backlinks from irrelevant, spammy, or low-quality websites.
If an agency suggests buying links, walk away. Google penalizes artificial link schemes.
9. Can you share an example of a campaign that didn’t go as planned?
Every business faces challenges. A transparent SEO agency should be willing to discuss past struggles and how they adapted.
Look for agencies that take responsibility, learn from setbacks, and focus on continuous improvement. If they claim every campaign has been flawless, they’re likely not being truthful.
10. How long will it take to see results?
SEO is a long-term investment. It typically takes six months to a year to see significant gains, though some improvements (like technical fixes) can yield quicker benefits.
Be wary of agencies promising overnight success. SEO requires patience, and lasting results come from consistent effort, quality content, and sustainable strategies.
11. Can you guarantee #1 rankings?
If an agency claims it can guarantee the top spot on Google, they are misleading you.
Rankings depend on hundreds of factors, many of which are outside an agency’s control, including Google’s algorithm updates and competitor activity.
A reputable agency will focus on improving rankings, increasing traffic, and driving conversions, rather than making empty promises.
Bonus: Ask About Money
SEO pricing varies widely. Some agencies charge flat rates, others work on retainers, and some offer performance-based pricing.
Before signing a contract, clarify:
- What is your payment structure?
- What’s included in the price?
- Is there a long-term commitment?
- Are there additional fees for content creation, link-building, or technical fixes?
If an agency offers SEO at a suspiciously low rate, be cautious. Cheap SEO often means cutting corners, using outdated tactics, or putting in minimal effort.
Make an Informed SEO Decision
Finding the right SEO agency isn’t about who makes the biggest promises—it’s about who can deliver consistent, sustainable results that help your business grow.
By asking these questions, you’ll gain the insight you need to hire a partner who prioritizes transparency, strategy, and long-term success.
SEO is an investment in your business’s future. Choose an agency that treats it that way.